It wasn’t intentional, but it so happened that I read couple of Kids’ fictions back to back. First one was John Grisham’s ‘Theodore Boone: Kid Lawyer’, followed by Keith Gray’s ‘Ostrich Boys’. I found the latter to be more interesting and gripping than the former. It was a surprise that the work of a famous author like John Grisham didn’t impress me as much as the work of a lesser known author Keith Gray.
Consider two situations:
A. your friend went for an adventurous trip and he narrates you his adventures.
B. your friend’s friend went for an adventurous trip and your friend narrates his friend’s adventures to you.
Which one would you prefer to hear?
Stories written in first person fascinates its readers a lot compared to stories written in third person. If there are only few characters in the story and apart from the main character, other characters can be detailed well using first person technique then always go for first person approach. Especially when the targeted readers are kids,
PS : It will be difficult for an author to narrate stories of ‘larger than life’ characters in first person without making the character sound like a narcissist. First person technique will also fail when there are hundreds of characters in the story.